Best Butt Plugs of 2018

For those of you who are butt plug first-timers we have decided to compile a list combined with of our favorites, reader picks, along with the most popular butt plugs on the MQ store.  Below is a list of the best butt plugs you can buy in 2018.


The Best Butt Plugs

Best butt plugs Tunnel anal Cover

Tunnel XL Butt Plug


Different from your typical butt plug, the Tunnel Plug has an opening running through the center.

This allows for airflow ( which feels pretty wild) and also lets you insert a secondary toy, fingers, or even get fucked through the center!



It is a stretchy material and lets you work up to some pretty impressive sizes.


The Tunnel Butt Plug is made of special mix of silicone and TPR called “PF Blend” which means it is safe with all lubes and won’t wear out over time like some other silicone butt plugs.

This is a toy that can grow with you, and provide different experiences depending on how you pair it.


MQ Reader Review:
“This Tunnel plug is a lot of fun because although it less than 3 inches wide, you can pull it over things like a water bottle or a fat dildo or whatever you can think of and then this toy becomes worth its weight in gold. You can make it any width you like by choosing the size of the insert. That is fucking HOT! The rubber is also very very soft and pliable too which makes insertion fun and comfortable too. This bad boy comes highly recommended from Rubberbutt. I can swallow a 4-inch wide toy in my hole so put things into perspective. You might want to start with a smaller size to test the waters first.” – RubberButt


Best butt plugs Tunnel anal medium

View XL Tunnel Butt Plug on:
MQ Store
$44.99 $36.72

Best butt plugs anal round cover

Round Butt Plug


For those looking for a little more “kink” in their new toy, the Round Butt Plug is a perfect fit.



This Butt Plug let’s you choose from three different sizes, ideal for those users who really want to stretch things out and take their anal fun to the next level.



MQ Reader Review:
“This plug is definitely not for the faint of heart. It will take a lot of prep time to get this big guy in but once you do, it provides a feeling like no other and you’ll never wanna take it out! I suggest loosening up with a giant dildo in your ass. Highly recommended!” – Anal Lover


Doc Johnson Round Butt Plug

View Round Butt Plug on:
MQ Store
$31.99 $27.41


Best butt plugs - Triple Ripple Anal Plug Cover

Triple Ripple Large Black Butt Plug


Moving on to the next level of anal play, the Tripple Ripple Butt Plug is rightly named – it is a wide, 2.3 inches with three separate stages, each giving a deeper, more fuller feeling.

This is a perfect toy for people who want to go big, but need a little extra help moving gradually to a more advanced butt plug.


The narrow tip gives a comfortable and easy insertion but is challenging enough later on as you move in deeper.


MQ Reader Review:
“Even though it says Large it’s a great size for experienced or beginners. Experienced, being me. Works you up with ease. Very smooth, holds lube well and cleans up very easy. Beginner, my wife. has a hard time with 1 and a half fingers, but can take the first bump with ease and can almost take the 2nd of 3. Made anal a lot easier for her to take and she loves this toy.” – J&T


Best butt plugs - Triple Ripple Anal Plug Product page

View Ripple Butt Plug on:
MQ Store
$34.69 $28.72


Best butt plugs - Classic Anal Plug

Classic Butt Plug Large Black


If you want a no frills, to the point (pun intended) butt plug with a more traditional design, then the Doc Johnson Classic is the one for you.

Similar to our top pick for an Anal Trainer kit, the Classic Butt Plug is another level up with a thicker, 2.2 width, and hefty 5-inch insertable length.



The standard, tapered shape means it is easier to work up to this larger size.   If you are looking to stretch things out then this is the one for you.


MQ Reader Review:
“You wanta fill your ass? Purchase this plug. It’s great and it only took me a day to get it to fit. This plug fills my ass with great pleasure. When I get stretched enough I guess I’ll have to go to the extra large plug. If you wanta get filled up buy this plug.”


Classic Anal Plug Product PageView Classic Butt Plug on:
MQ Store
$34.99 $23.67


Best butt plugs - Colt Anal Dilator Kit Cover

Colt Anal Dilator Kit


Not just one of the best butt plugs, but also the best value.  The Colt Anal Dilator kit gives you three different sized plugs that let you start small and work your way up to pro level.



The narrow tips are easy to insert, and the sizing is well spaced to let you progress at your own pace.  This puts the Anal Dilator kit as one of the best butt plugs you can buy right now.

MQ Reader Review:
“This product made anal play much more fun and easier than I could’ve ever imagined it would be. I’d definitely recommend for those who might be skeptical. Quality product made with quality materials, easy to clean, and my new favorite!” – Chris


View Colt Anal Dilator Kit Colt Anal Dilator kit 3 Butt Plugs product Pageon:
MQ Store
$52.99 $46.87


Best butt plugs - 50 Shades of Grey Cover

50 Shades Forbidden Butt Plug


If you are in the market for a high quality plug, the 50 Shades Forbidden Butt Plug is the answer.



The material is extra soft, made from high quality, skin-soft silicone.  The narrow sup is easy to insert and the handle ring is simple to handle making it the best butt plug in its category.


MQ Reader Review:
“This was the first toy I had ever owned and I still love it. The silicon is super smooth and easy to insert. It has the added benefit of being able to be frozen for temp play.” – Jessica


50 Shades of Grey Butt Plug Product PageView 50 Shades Butt Plug on:
MQ Store
$33.08 $27.49


Best butt plugs - Chrystal Jellies Anal Delight Cover

Crystal Jellies Anal Delight


The Crystal Jellies is somewhere between an anal dildo and a butt plug.  The thin size is ideal for beginners but the length adds a much more satisfying feel making it one of the best butt plugs for first timers.



The notched beads add sensation and help to make the experience more pleasurable.  The Jellie comfortable, durable and a cinch to clean up after too.

Chrystal Jellies Anal Delight Product Page

View Crystal Jellies on:
MQ Store
$34.99 $31.27


The Best Butt Plugs - Cock Plug Cover

Cock Plug


All the function of a butt plug with all the fun of a cock mixed in.  The Cock Plug is sized and shaped much like many other plugs, but gives you a more realistic feeling of a cock inside.  The penis head is a satisfying addition to the package to say the least.


MQ Reader Review:
“If you like your anal plugs to look like a real cock, these are the ideal.  I find these are good sizes to train and prepare your anus for anal sex. They are non-toxic pvc and easy to clean.” – CockLover


Cock Anal Plug Product Page View Cock Plug on:
MQ Store
$32.99 $25.71


Read More:

The Best Anal Lubes Cover

How to Have Anal Sex Guide

The Best Anal Dildos Cover

the best cock rings

The Best Prostate Massagers Cover

The Best Anal Vibrators Cover


If you have any questions or would rather ask us directly feel free to email us at [email protected] or write them down in the comments below!


There you have it, our picks for the best butt plugs of 2017. Have you tried any of the above butt plugs?  Do you have any recommendations for readers?  Leave your thoughts in the comments below.


1 Comment

  1. Will i am
    September 22, 2017 9:16 pm Reply

    I Need an explosion in my ass while my cock stays hard for hours

Leave a reply