Best Butt Plugs Tested! Top 20 Anal Toys of 2024

Best Butt Plugs Anal Toys

For those of you who are butt plug first-timers, we have decided to compile a list combined with our favorites, reader picks, along with the most popular butt plugs on the MQ store.  Below is a list of the best butt plugs you can buy this year.

mr q male sex toy buyers guide

What are the Best Butt Plugs?

mr q male anal trainer sex toy

Butt Plugs are a popular tool for anal play, regardless of gender. The best butt plugs come in variety of shapes, sizes and materials. We are here to help you choose the right size and style for your needs and experience. Whether you are a beginner or pro, we created this guide to help you get started.

Anal Plug Trainer Kits

mr q recommends male best sex toys

If this is your first time using an anal toy, then we highly recommend starting with an anal dilator kit. These are typically a set of 3 to 4 staged plugs that start small and gradually move up to bigger, thicker sizes. This is perfect if you are unsure about where to start or what size plug you can comfortable handle.

Colt Anal Dilator Kit

Colt Anal Plug Dilator Starter Kit

Not just one of the best butt plugs, but also the best value.  The Colt Anal Dilator kit gives you three different-sized plugs that let you start small and work your way up to the pro level.

The narrow tips are easy to insert, and the sizing is well-spaced to let you progress at your own pace.  This puts the Anal Dilator kit as one of the best butt plugs you can buy right now.

MQ Reader Review:
“This made anal play much more fun and easier than I could’ve ever imagined. I’d definitely recommend for those who might be skeptical about anal. Quality product, easy to clean, and works well. My new favorite!” – Chris

Material: Phthalate-Free PVC
Diameter: 1in.-1.5in. (2.3cm. -3.8 cm.) 
Insertable-Length: 4in.-5.5in (10 cm. – 14 cm.) 
Features: 3 Staged Sizes 
Difficulty Level: Anal First-Timers – Intermediate

Colt Anal Trainer Kit of 3

View on: MQ Store

Original price was: $69.99.Current price is: $58.71.Add to cart

Anal trainer kits are some of the best butt plugs thanks to their beginner friendliness. Start with a small plug, and work your way to more advanced sizes. In this category, our stand-out, top seller and highest recommendation is the Colt Anal Dilator Kit.

Silicone Starter Plugs

best dildo men silicone anal trainer kit 3

Silicone toys are body safe, durable, and made from non-toxic materials. They are generally a bit more expensive than traditional rubber PVC toys, with the added benefit of being longer-lasting and fragrance free. This features even thinner plugs, with the smallest less than 1 inch in diameter. This makes it even more accessible for even the tightest beginners.

Material: Silicone
Hands-Free Suction Cup Base
Fully Waterproof and Water Submersible
Difficulty Level: First-Timers to Intermediate

Anal Trainer Kit set of 3 Sizes

View on: MQ Store

Original price was: $54.99.Current price is: $39.78.Add to cart

Glass Anal Training Trio

glass anal training trio best butt plug

Compared to plastics like PVC that many sex toys are made from, high-strength Tempered Glass is a great alternative. Not only do they offer a more stiff (and therefore more stimulating) experience, they are also much easier to clean, maintain, and you don’t need to worry about them wearing down over time.

Although the Glass Trainer kit comes at a bit of a premium, the extra cost comes with a higher quality, more durable product with extra peace of mind.

Material: High-Strength Tempered Glass
Non-allergic, Non-porous, Easy to Clean
Small Plug: 4.55 in. by 1.15 in.
Medium: 5 in. by 1.35 in.
Large: 5.75 in. by 1.5 in.

glass anal training butt plug kit
Glass Anal Trainer Kit of 3

View on: MQ Store

Original price was: $79.99.Current price is: $69.97.Add to cart

Dark Invader Aluminum Silicone Anal Plug

Dark Invader Aluminum Silicone Anal Best Butt Plugs

Aluminum butt plugs are some of the best butt plug materials to choose from. Not only is aluminum lightweight, it is also resistant to germs and bacteria, and easy to clean.

Dark Invader Aluminum Silicone Anal Best Butt Plugs Sizes
Dark Invader Aluminum Plugs come in 3 Sizes

The Dark Invader butt plug series comes with a medical-grade silicone base with a large grip for better control. One of our favorite features is the ability to pre-heat or cool these plugs for even more fun.

Material: Aluminium Body, Silicone Base
Large Plug: Insertable Length 3.5 in. Diameter 1.6 in.
Medium Plug: Insertable length 3 in. Diameter 1.3 in.
Small Plug: Insertable length 2.5 in. Diameter 1 in.

Dark Invader Aluminum Silicone Anal Plug 3
Dark Invader Aluminum – Medium

View on: MQ Store

Original price was: $54.99.Current price is: $46.81.Add to cart

Novelty Plugs

In this category, we choose some of the most unique plugs with features you wouldn’t imagine. These are the best butt plugs that are new, innovative, and sure to please.

Tunnel Butt Plug

Tunnel Best Butt Plug XL Clear

The best butt plug is the Tunnel Anal Plug because of its unique design and versatility. The hollow design allows natural airflow and the ability to stretch to different sizes. Best of all, it can be used with a variety of other anal toys. Different from your typical butt plug, the Tunnel Plug has an opening running through the center.

tunnel XL Clear

This allows for airflow ( which feels pretty wild) and also lets you insert a secondary toy, fingers, or even get fucked through the center! It is a stretchy material and lets you work up to some pretty impressive sizes.


The Tunnel Butt Plug is made of a special mix of silicone and TPR called “PF Blend” which means it is safe with all lubes and won’t wear out over time like some other silicone butt plugs. This is a toy that can grow with you, and provide different experiences depending on how you pair it.

MQ Reader Review:
“This Tunnel plug is a lot of fun. You can pull it over things like a water bottle or a fat dildo or whatever you can think of! That is fucking HOT! The rubber is also very very soft and pliable, which makes insertion fun and comfortable too. I can swallow a 4-inch wide toy in my hole to put things into perspective. You might want to start with a smaller size to test the waters first.” – RubberButt

Material: Ultra-Flex Silicone and TPR Blend
Medium:Length: 2.5 in. (6.3 cm) Width: 2 in. (5 cm)
Large: Length: 3 in. (7.6 cm) Width: 2.2 in. (5.6 cm)
XL Plug:Length: 4 in. (10 cm) Width: 2.85 in. (7.2 cm)
Hollow, Look-Inside Design

Tunnel Anal Plug Clear – Medium

View on: MQ Store

Original price was: $62.99.Current price is: $54.72.Add to cart

Inflatable Butt Plug

Expandable Butt Plug Latex Red Black

The inflatable Plug is a Butt Plug that grows with you! The plug is a manageable 3.75 in. by 1.5 in. before inflation. The included hand pump lets you control the size and inflate while inserted inside.

At its maximum, it can grow to almost 3 times its original size. For a toy with a bit more challenge and kink, it is easily one of the best butt plugs of the year.

Expandable Butt Plug Latex inflatable

Material: Pure Latex Plug
Length: 3.75 in.
Width: 1.5 in.
Upto 3x Inflatable Width


View on MQ Store

Original price was: $40.76.Current price is: $37.05.Add to cart

Ass Gasm Butt Plug Cock-Ring

Assgasm cock ring

The Ass-Gasm combines the best of using a cock ring, with a prostate butt plug merged into one. The Plug/Ring combo is made from medical-grade silicone that is soft, and extra comfortable to wear. With its duo stimulation, the Ass Gasm is one of the best butt plugs we have tested designed especially for men.

Material: Silicone
Insertable Length: 4 in.
Width: 1.25 in.
Cock Ring Diameter: 1.5 in.
Cock Ring Anal Plug Combo
Difficulty Level: Anal First-Timers

AssGasm Cock Ring Plug

View on: MQ Store

Original price was: $49.99.Current price is: $42.87.Add to cart

Triple Play Anal Plug

triple play best anal plug

How about 3 times the fun in one single toy? The Triple play anal plug is a 3-way plug set that gets more challenging as you rotate it.

With the plug inserted, the other 2 plugs work as a handle, allowing you to maneuver your toy. Made from super smooth silicone, it has a quality feel and is easy to clean and maintain. Looking to add a ninja star to your butt plug collection? This may be it.

Triple Play Butt Plug

View Triple Play Plug on MQ Store

Original price was: $39.60.Current price is: $36.00.Add to cart

Tailz Fox Tail Anal Plug and Ears Set

best butt plugs tailz fox

The Tailz Series anal plug is your standard anal plug with a Fox Tail built-in. Simply insert your butt plug and transform it into your sexual fantasy.


The Tailz set comes with the Anal Plug tail as well as a headband with ears to help you transform into your furry friend.

Tailz Fox Tail and Ears Set

View Tailz Anal Plug on: MQ Store

Original price was: $89.99.Current price is: $78.47.Add to cart

Dildo Butt Plugs

best anal dildos and dongs

Dildo butt plugs are a combination of these two sex toy categories. They come in a butt plug form factor, with a stopper at the base. These are some of the best butt plugs if you want to add a bit of realism to your anal toy.

Jellies Anal Starter Dildo Plug

Jellies starter anal Dildo

The Crystal Jellies is somewhere between an anal dildo and a butt plug.  The thin size is ideal for beginners but the length adds a much more satisfying feel making it one of the best butt plugs for first-timers.

The notched beads add sensation and help to make the experience more pleasurable.  The Jellies is comfortable, durable, and a cinch to clean up after too.

MQ Reader Review
As a beginner, I really liked the Jellies anal dildo. It is very soft and flexible. It has a small head for easy entry, a perfect length, and width for beginners. It’s a perfect starter toy!”

Material: Anti-Bacterial PVC Jelly
Diameter: 1 in.
Insertable-Length: 5.7 in.
Features: Hands-Free Suction Cup
Difficulty Level: First-Timers (No Anal Experience)

Jellies starter anal Dildo Clear
Jellies Anal Starter – Clear

View on: MQ Store

Original price was: $32.99.Current price is: $27.99.Add to cart

Temptasia Reina Suction Cup Dildo

reina temptasia best dildo men

All the functions of a butt plug with all the fun of a cock mixed in.  The Temptasia is sized and shaped much like many other plugs, but gives you a more realistic feeling of a cock inside.  The penis head is a satisfying addition to the package to say the least. Thanks to its realistic shape and girth size, the Reina swoops in as yet another of the best butt plugs of the year.

MQ Reader Review:
“I’m new to sex toys and have always been hesitant. I saw this one, read the reviews and had to try it. It is great! Just the right size, nicely curved to fit and feels amazingly like the real thing.”

Temptasia Reina Silicone Dildo

Material: Silicone
Strong Suction Cup Base
Smooth Glide Body
Insertable Length:
5.5 in. (14 cm)
Diameter: 1.4 in. (3.5 cm)
Fragrance & Phthalate Free

Temptasia Reina Teal G Spot Dildo 3
Temptasia Prostate Dildo

View on: MQ Store

Original price was: $49.99.Current price is: $41.42.Add to cart

Rounded Butt Plugs

These are classic butt plugs that are smooth, bendable, and meant for anal training. We have included some of the best butt plugs in various materials, shapes in sizes for you to choose from.

Round Luxe Butt Plug

Performance Wearable Vibro

For those looking for a little more “kink” in their new toy, the Round Butt Plug is a perfect fit. This Butt Plug lets you choose from three different sizes, ideal for those users who really want to stretch things out and take their anal fun to the next level.

Integrated Vibro Ball

MQ Reader Review:
“This plug is definitely not for the faint of heart. It will take a lot of prep time to get this big guy in but once you do, it provides a feeling like no other and you’ll never wanna take it out! I suggest loosening up with a giant dildo in your ass. Highly recommended!” – Anal Lover

The Wearable Vibro Plug’s most impressive feature is the battery-free Vibro ball interior that responds to each movement of your body. Even the slightest movement sends silent vibrations throughout the plug. 

Length: 3.3 in.
Insertable Length: 2.8 in.
Width: 1.8 in.
Material: Medical-Grade Silicone
Integrated Battery-Free Vibro Ball


View on MQ Store

Original price was: $29.99.Current price is: $28.72.Add to cart

Triple Ripple Large Black Butt Plug

Triple Ripple Anal Plug Black

Moving on to the next level of anal play, the Tripple Ripple Butt Plug is rightly named as one of the best butt plugs of the year- it is a wide, 2.3 inches with three separate stages, each giving a deeper, fuller feeling.

MQ Reader Review:
“Very smooth, holds lube well and cleans up very easy. Beginner, my wife, has a hard time with 1 and a half fingers, but can take the first bump with ease and can almost take the 2nd of 3. Made anal a lot easier for her to take and she loves this toy.” – J&T

This is a perfect toy for people who want to go big, but need a little extra help moving gradually to a more advanced butt plug. The narrow tip gives a comfortable and easy insertion but is challenging enough later on as you move in deeper.

Triple Ripple Butt Plug

View on MQ Store

Original price was: $38.99.Current price is: $34.78.Add to cart

Luxe Explore Butt Plug

Luxe Explore Best Butt Plugs

The Luze Explore Silicone Butt plug is somewhere between an anal plug and anal beads. With a two-stage bulb you can start slow and gradually go bigger and deeper. The handle at the base makes for a comfortable gripper and doubles as an ergonomic stopper.

Length: 4.5 in
Insertable Length: 4 in
Width: 1.3 in.
Circumference: 4.17 in
Material: Medical-Grade Silicone

Luxe Explore Butt Plug 2

View on MQ Store

Original price was: $29.99.Current price is: $24.87.Add to cart

Vibrating Plugs

The following toys add an extra level of stimulation to enhance your experience when wearing them. Thanks to the extra buzz and vibration these toys can help send you over the edge.

Vibrating AssGasm

AssGasm Vibrating best prostate massagers anal

The AssGasm also coves in a vibrating variant for even more stimulation. The plug bulb has an insertable vibrating bullet with a changeable battery.

Like the standard version, the starter kit includes the plug, lube, and toy cleaner to get you started.

Material: Silicone
Removable Vibrating Bullet
Cock Ring Butt Plug Combo
Plug Insertable Length:
3.5 in. Diameter: 1.4 In.

Vibrating AssGasm

View on MQ Store

Original price was: $69.99.Current price is: $62.71.Add to cart

Little Thumper Vibrating Butt Plug

Luxe Little Thumper Vibrating Best Butt Plugs

An anal vibrator? An anal plug? The Little Thumper is an anal vibrating plug 2-in-1. This butt plug as an insertable vibrating motor with a changeable battery. This simple addition made using this butt plug a totally different experience than other toys on the list. Coming in pink and black these two make a fun pair. The build is overall solid, and the silicone body feels great to use.

10 Vibrating Functions
Waterproof Bullet Vibrator

Batteries: 1 AAA battery, not included.
Material: Silicone
Length: 4.75 in. Insertable: 3.5 in.
Plug Width: 1.5 in.

Luxe Little Thumper Vibrating Best Butt Plugs Black

View on MQ Store

Original price was: $45.99.Current price is: $39.87.Add to cart

My Secret Remote Vibrating XL Plug

Screaming O My Secret Remote Vibrating XL Plug Black

The My Secret Remote Vibrating Butt Plug is not only big – it vibrates. This Extra-Large size comes in at 4 inches insertable and a girthy 1.75 inches.

The wireless remote can work up to 40 feet away, and the plug can also be controlled via the base’s integrated buttons. This plug is rechargeable with 60 minutes of play per charge.

Screaming O XXL Vibrating Butt Plug

Insertable Length: 4 in.
Plug Diameter: 1.75 in.
Wireless Remote Control
Rechargeable Battery
60 Minutes of Play Per Charge

Best Butt Plugs Tested! Top 20 Anal Toys of 2024 1

View on: MQ Store

Original price was: $116.73.Current price is: $110.06.Add to cart

Best Big Butt Plugs

These butt plugs are for the advanced user, or anyone looking to go extra big (and deep). We have chosen plugs that are bigger than almost any other toys on this list. These are the best butt plugs for extreme anal play.

Colossus XXL Silicone Anal Suction Cup Plug

Colossus XXL Silicone Anal Suction Cup biggest sex toys

Fill yourself up with Colossus XXL Silicone Anal Plug and thank me later for finding this one of the biggest sex toys. Since butt plugs are normally used to loosen you up, kind of like an entre to a four courses meal. This one is without a doubt the best choice for that!

It has a tapered shape to ensure maximum stimulation with comfort. It is huge compared to other butt plugs in the market, but it’s still in the manageable range. Firm and strong suction cup for even easier use when you’re playing solo.

Colossus XXL Silicone Anal Suction Cup in hand

View on: MQ Store

Original price was: $82.76.Current price is: $75.24.Add to cart

Classic Butt Plug Large

classic butt plug black

If you want a no-frills, to-the-point (pun intended) butt plug with a more traditional design, then the Doc Johnson Classic is the one for you.

Similar to our top pick for an Anal Trainer kit, the Classic Butt Plug is another level up with a thicker, 2-width, and hefty 4.2-inch insertable length. The standard, tapered shape means it is easier to work up to this larger size.   If you are looking to stretch things out then this is the one for you.

MQ Reader Review:
“You wanna fill your ass? Purchase this plug. It’s great and it only took me a day to get it to fit. This plug fills my ass and makes me feel full. When I get stretched enough I guess I’ll have to go to the extra large plug.”

Classic Butt Plug Large Black
Classic Butt Plug Large

View on: MQ Store

Original price was: $34.99.Current price is: $31.99.Add to cart

Titanmen Intimidator Plug

Titanmen Anal Stretcher butt plug biggest sex toys

Let’s start your anal playtime with one of the biggest sex toys out there. AKA, Titanmen Intimidator Plug. 11” of insertable length will give you the wildest sensation for opening up your hole. The ribbed design makes it so that the deeper you go, the better it feels.


MQ User Review:
I have had this plug for a month and enjoy the plug greatly. Right now, I am about 3/4 down it already. I am working on getting farther and farther until I sit on my seat with it all in!! With a 4″ base this is not going to be that easy to get all of it in my for quite a while. I am moving up to the 2.75″ from the 2.5″ plugs!!

Cone shape makes it easier for people who are looking for a way to practice and slowly adjust to bigger things. Trying to find the perfect entrance into the extremely big toys world, look no further, this is it! Now the question is how far can you go? Choose from the 6-inch, or the 11-inch for extra size.

Intimidator Stretch 11 Inch
Intimidator 11 Inch

View on: MQ Store

Original price was: $139.99.Current price is: $112.72.Add to cart

How to Use a Butt Plug

How to Use a Butt Plug Anal Play

After you get the right supplies, be sure to check out our full in-depth guide on how to use a butt plug too.

Butt Plug Video Guide on YouTube

For more in-depth walk-throughs about sex toys and anal play you can also refer to our guides below.

Flush Things Out With an Enema

mr q male anal enema

Enemas are the best way to clean up before using an anal plug. Enemas work by injecting water inside to flush out any surprises that might still be lingering behind. For most people, a medium-sized enema will do the trick!

Removable Enema Tip
Smoothed Tube for Easy Insertion
EZ-Squeeze Enema Bulb
4 Sizes to Choose From

anal enemas pros douche sizes
Universal Enema Medium 160ml

View on MQ Store

Original price was: $24.99.Current price is: $24.97.Add to cart

Use an Anal Lube

mr q male anal lube sex toy

To make things smooth and comfortable, it is essential to use a quality Anal lube! We have a full list of anal lubes here. For most people, Pjur Analyse Me is our top pick because it includes an anal relaxant, is toy friendly, and long-lasting.

Relaxing Ingredient: Jojoba Extract
Relaxing Strength: ⭐☆☆☆☆
Lube Thickness: 3/5
Toy Compatible

Pjur Analyse me Comfort
Pjur Analyse Me Water 100ml

View on MQ Store

Original price was: $37.99.Current price is: $32.73.Add to cart

How to Clean Your Anal Plug

male q sex toy cleaner

Toy cleaner is an easy way to keep your butt plug fresh and free of bacteria and funny smells. Toy cleaner will help keep your toy hygienic and safe to use. It is definitely money well spent.

Toy cleaner is a great way to keep your toy fresh, hygienic, and odor-free.

Universal Toy Cleaner 4oz
Anti-Bacterial Toy Cleaner 4.3oz

View on MQ Store

Original price was: $24.99.Current price is: $19.78.Add to cart

Anal Sex Starter Kit

best anal sex starter kit toys

The Anal trainer kit also comes in a starter bundle with lube, toy cleaner, enema, and lube shooter for everything you need to get started.

3 Plug Silicone Anal Trainer Kit
2 Cock Rings
2 Lube Injectors
Anal Enema (90ml)
Pjur Analyse Me Lube (100ml)
Toy Cleaner (100ml)

anal sex starter kit Silicone
Anal Sex Starter Kit

View on: MQ Store

Original price was: $149.99.Current price is: $112.72.Add to cart

If you have any questions about choosing the best butt plugs or any other questions, feel free to email us at [email protected] or write them down in the comments below!

Mr Q Read More 2023
best male sex toys
dr joel prostate massager dildo
best prostate massagers p spot stimulators
Best Anal Vibrators Cover
Best cock rings penis
Best Lubricants and lubes for sex

There you have it, our picks for the best butt plugs of the year. Have you tried any of the above butt plugs?  Do you have any recommendations for readers?  Leave your thoughts in the comments below.

Related Articles


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. I can’t recommend the tripple ripple enough. It’s so easy to progress from the small top to the HUGE bottom section, really you won’t believe how good it feels. I started slow and was able to take the first 2 sections easily, it took a little more time to take the bottom, but the feeling when you it almost indescribable!